Skip to main content

Phyllis’s Comeback Sauce

This creamy, tangy descendant of Thousand Island and remoulade originated in the Greek restaurants of Jackson, Mississippi. From there it spread like wildfire to every salad, burger, fried fish, and French fry in the surrounding five counties and beyond. Most anything edible makes an acceptable receptacle for my friend Phyllis’s version.

Recipe information

  • Yield

    makes about 2 cups

Ingredients

1 cup your favorite or Homemade Mayonnaise (page 280)
1/2 cup ketchup
1/2 cup chili sauce
2 tablespoons grated onion
2 tablespoons Worcestershire sauce
Juice of 1 lemon
1 tablespoon white wine vinegar
1 tablespoon ground sweet paprika
2 garlic cloves, smashed and minced
2 teaspoons Colman’s dry mustard
Sea salt and freshly ground black pepper

Preparation

  1. Combine the mayonnaise, ketchup, chili sauce, onion, Worcestershire sauce, lemon juice, vinegar, paprika, garlic, and mustard in a bowl and whisk to mix well. Season with salt and pepper to taste and refrigerate in an airtight container until ready to use, or for up to 4 days.

Reprinted with permission from Sara Foster's Southern Kitchen: Soulful, Traditional, Seasonal by Sara Foster. Copyright © 2011 by Sara Foster. Published by Random House. All Rights Reserved. Sara Foster is the owner of Foster's Market, the acclaimed gourmet take-out store/cafés in Durham and Chapel Hill, North Carolina, and the author of several cookbooks including The Foster's Market Cookbook, winner of the Best Cookbook Award from the Southeast Booksellers Association. She has appeared numerous times on Martha Stewart Living Television and NBC's Today show. She has also been featured in magazines such as More, House Beautiful, and Southern Living, and is featured regularly in Bon Appétit.
Read More
Like a cucumber-cilantro chutney sandwich and scallop piccata.
A veg-forward main or gets-along-with-everyone side.
A warmly spiced Ashkenazi charoset, perfect for your Passover seder—or spooned over yogurt the next morning.
Keep this easy frittata recipe on hand for quick breakfasts, impressive brunches, and fridge clean-out meals.
Turn humble onions into this thrifty yet luxe pasta dinner.
Like airy lemon chiffon cake and a Cadbury egg–inspired tart.
Dressed in a spiced yogurt, with ginger and garlic, then roasted until caramelized and tender.
Think a Hugo spritz, a gin basil smash, and plenty more patio-ready pours.