Skip to main content

Pie

Peanut and Caramel Ice Cream Pie

Layer store-bought vanilla ice cream with peanut butter, caramel sauce, and a peanut–graham cracker crust for the ultimate summer dessert indulgence.

Chocolate Cinnamon Cream Pie

We love the cinnamon in Mexican chocolate. For this pie, we surround a smooth chocolate-pudding filling with cinnamon—a crumbly spiced graham cracker crust below and cinnamon whipped cream on top.

Lattice Apple Pie with Mexican Brown Sugar

We took a regular apple-pie recipe and sweetened the filling with Mexican piloncillo, an unrefined brown sugar. What a difference a sugar makes. This one has a lot of character and adds syrupy molasses notes to a blend of sweet and tart apples.

Lemon Chess Pie

Next to brown sugar pie, this is my favorite chess pie. There are several theories as to how these pies came by their name. Some say that "chess" is a corruption of “chest,” meaning that these pies were so rich they could be stored in chests at room temperature. Others offer a different explanation: It seems that long ago when a good plantation cook was asked what she was making, she replied, "Jes pie," which over time became "chess." Still others insist that "chess" derives from “cheese,” as in the English lemon "cheese" (or curd). According to food historian Karen Hess, "cheese" was spelled "chese" in seventeenth-century England. In her historical notes and commentaries for the 1984 facsimile edition of Mary Randolph’s Virginia House-wife (1824), Hess writes: "Since the archaic spellings of cheese often had but one 'e' we have the answer to the riddle of the name of that southern favorite ‘Chess Pie.' " When I lived in New York, I baked dozens of lemon chess pies for the annual Gramercy Park fund-raiser and they sold as fast as I could unpack them. From that experience, I learned to buzz up the filling in the food processor. I even grate the lemon zest by processor. Here’s how: Strip the zest from the lemons with a swivel-bladed vegetable peeler, then churn it with the sugar to just the right texture. I next pulse in the lemon juice, then the eggs one by one. Finally, I drizzle the melted butter down the feed tube with the motor running. That’s all there is to it.

Pumpkin Butterscotch Pie

In this fun take on pumpkin pie, a little whisky really puts the "Scotch" in butterscotch.

Pumpkin Ice Cream Pie with Chocolate-Almond Bark and Toffee Sauce

Purchased vanilla ice cream, pumpkin, and four different spices make up the delicious pie filling.

French Apple Turnovers (Chaussons Aux Pommes)

All-butter puff pastry is available at some specialty foods stores.

Caramelized-Apple and Pecan Pie

This dessert is a pecan pie-apple pie hybrid.

Maple Hazelnut Pie

Not as rich as pecans, hazelnuts make for a delicious new spin on a southern classic. Use Grade B maple syrup for intense maple flavor.

Blueberry Pie with Cornmeal Crust and Lemon Cream

In this gorgeous pie, blueberry meets its perfect match: lemon.

Fresh Strawberry Pie with Whipped Cream

There is nothing like this pie. It was created by test kitchen director Ruth Cousineau, and if there were ever a laurel to rest on, this would be it. The berries are key, so look for local ones (those that travel least taste the best) that are plump, fragrant, and fully ripe, with no white shoulders. One of the miracles here is that the gelatin will be set just enough so that you can easily cut a slice, but it's not bouncy.

Honey, Date, and Pecan Tart

Honey and dates make this dessert perfectly sweet (but not too sweet) and sticky. Pecans add a nutty crunch.

Harvest Tart

Brushing the pastry with egg adds shine while it bakes.

Lemon Meringue Pie

This grand old American dessert is enormously popular down South for its clear, true sweetness (saved by the edginess of lemon) and its masterful contrast of textures. And somehow it is show-stopping (think beauty pageant) and homey (think Aunt Bee) simultaneously.

Bittersweet Chocolate Pudding Pie with Crème Fraîche Topping

An intense dark-chocolate filling topped with sweet-tangy cream.

Peach Blueberry Pie

To keep the pie crust from getting soggy, brush the bottom with egg white.

King Orchard's Sour Cherry Pie

Sour cherries have a short season. If you can't find fresh ones, use quick-frozen or canned sour cherries.

Bittersweet Chocolate Pecan Pie

Here we've taken pecan pie above and beyond its usual corn-syrupy incarnation. A layer of bittersweet chocolate adds richness to the dessert while simultaneously balancing its sweetness. And an abundance of pecans makes for a supremely satisfying filling.
42 of 64